8/8/15

Learning to Write

When I created our Name Folders, one of the many ways that we teach children to recognize, spell and write their names, I did not anticipate such a stir about the fact that our younger students write their names with capital letters. People ask, "Why are you teaching in all capitals?" and comment, "Nice idea, but it's so frustrating to have to break bad habits like these." Some admonish me to, "please, please, please teach them lower case letters from the start!" Many people feel that, "It should be taught correctly as soon as they learn to write."

Every lesson and learning objective that I plan for my class is intentional. I have a degree in early childhood education and a masters in reading education; I am a thinker and a planner. My choice to write their names in capitals is not accidental or ill-advised. It is an intentional decision and I'd love to explain.
Capitals or Lower Case debate
Writing sample of a Pre-K student, age 4.10
Young children are surrounded by capital letters.
We all know about the influence of environmental print. Young toddlers who cannot identify any letters can likely "read" Sesame Street, Subway, and Stop because of the powers of environmental print. 
They might have their names on their bedroom walls and wooden toys like these in their playrooms. Capital letters are everywhere.
Capital Letters are easier to recognize and easier to write.
Capital letters are usually easier for children to recognize because they are still developing visual discrimination skills. Many lower case letters look alike. Imagine being a young child. Which of these is easier to identify?
upper case vs lower case
Children are also developing their fine motor skills. The capital letters tend to have simpler lines than the lower case letters. For example, the capital E has 4 straight lines, while the lower case e requires more a much more sophisticated movement.
Writing sample of a Pre-K student, age 5.2

Most children can identify more capital letters than lower case.
In Virginia, our benchmark for kindergarten readiness (based on the PALS assessment) is 12-21 upper case letters and only 9-18 lower case letters. When our students arrive in the fall, we do a quick check to see how many letters they know. This past year, 4 out of my 10 pre-k students recognized zero lower case letters. If students only recognize capital letters, they are only going to write in capital letters. Increasing alphabet knowledge is an important component in learning to write.
Writing sample (and artwork!) from a Pre-K student, age 4.8

Most importantly, learning to write is a developmental process. Using capital letters is part of that development. It is not a bad habit!
All learning is developmental. Here are a few examples:
  • Infants crawl, pull up to standing, take a few steps, then toddle around before they learn to walk "properly." We would never discourage a toddler from cruising the furniture out of fear that it would foster bad walking habits!
  • Children learn to babble before they speak in single words. Then they string a few words together before making a complete sentence. Once they've mastered that, they may be able to carry on longer conversations. We would never discourage a child from saying, "Mama, up!" out of fear that he would develop bad speaking habits. Eventually, he will learn to say, "Mommy, please pick me up!"
  • The same is true with writing. Children begin by scribbling. Then they make letter-like symbols and start to string random letters together. As they learn more about their name, they write its letters, even if some are reversed or missing. We do not discourage this type of writing, or insist that the children write their names conventionally! It is just a part of the process -- not a bad habit.


Teachers know their children best.
Like other teachers, I know my children very well and constantly strive to meet them where they are in their development. Do you remember Lev Vygotsky and his Zone of Proximal Development? His theory is that we always work toward what the students can do with a bit of instructional support. It's that sweet spot between work that is too easy, and work that is currently out of reach because it's too difficult. When my students show signs that they are ready to use lower case letters, or in January of their Pre-K year (whichever comes first), we move to conventional name writing. The 4-year-old who wrote his name below is not quite ready for conventional writing. His goal is to identify and include all of the letters, and it will likely be with capitals.
Writing sample of a preschool student, age 4.3

Model, Scaffold, and Support
Finally, it is important to model conventional names for our children. All of the names that are posted (everywhere!) in our classroom are written with an initial upper case and subsequent lower case letters. Every time the children see me write their names, it is conventional. 
Simultaneously we work on our fine motor skills (see examples herehere, and here) to build on the skills that the children are developing.

We celebrate when the students return from winter break in January of Pre-K that it is actually their kindergarten year! We talk about all of the wonderful things that might happen (losing teeth, riding the school bus, going to the "big school"). I make a big deal about the fact that now that they are almost ready for kindergarten, they have to start using lower case letters in their names. Instead of being frustrated, this is motivating for our 5-year-olds. They want to be big kids! They want to do things like a kindergartner! With few exceptions (there are always some kids who are just not quite ready) my students leave Pre-K writing their names conventionally. They do it because we have supported their development as they learn to write their names at age 3 and 4.
Writing sample of a Pre-K student, age 5.5
I'd love to know what you think. Should preschoolers be required to write their names with lower case letters?

You can read more about how we teach children their names in these posts:
    

Powerful Mothering has a wonderful FREE printable page that you can edit (capitals or lower case!) for your children to practice writing their names. Click HERE:
Follow this board for tons of name ideas:
Follow Play to Learn Preschool's board Literacy: Name Games on Pinterest.
Here are some of the writing products that we use, for your convenience.


27 comments:

  1. What a GREAT post! Learning to read and write is a developmental thing, just like walking and talking. We are always encouraging and helping our kids to move past one developmental stage to another. Love, love, love! I'm so glad you posted this. Going to share away!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much Becky. I completely agree, and I appreciate your support. :)

      Delete
  2. Thanks for this. Love your clear explanations. I totally agree with you. I really get annoyed when teachers further down the line forget what they learned in their Human Development and Educational Psychology classes about preschoolers. We seem to have developed a culture that thinks we can just teach everything earlier to get ahead and it ends up sometimes making kids who are not ready totally lose out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Laura. I also get frustrated at times when we expect things from our children that they just aren't ready for yet. We want to follow their lead and develop a strong love of learning!

      Delete
  3. Thank you for sharing this so clearly and concisely. It is the way studentsshould and need to be taught. Well Done!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment Kathy. All teachers need to do what's best for their children, and this is definitely what's best for mine.

      Delete
  4. What a beautiful explanation for your choice!
    I definitely agree, capital letters are easier to recognize for preschoolers, and with mostly straight lines, easier to write. I started both of mine with writing their names in all capital letters. It was not a difficult transition for them to start learning to write their name with a capital letter and lower case letters when the time came.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's my experience, too, Christina. When the students have a solid grasp of their name in capitals and they have good fine motor skills, the transition to lower case is rather easy. It's important that we follow their lead! Thanks so much for your comment.

      Delete
  5. Excellent explanation for doubters!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I think it is a good topic for discussion!

      Delete
  6. Cursive makes p d and be look different... it is also like a child's scribbles. That is why Montessori starts with it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's very true. I think cursive is easier to write, but because most of the books and print that children read are in manuscript many programs teach children to write those first.

      Delete
  7. Thank you for your comment! Confidence is so important, and those little letters are tricky. Have a great school year.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for sharing your reasons behind your decision Jamie. Developmentally appropriate practices tend to fall by the wayside with the push for children to do more sooner. I like that you meet the children where they are, but continue to model the conventional spelling for them.

    Tammy
    The Resourceful Apple

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much Tammy. It seems to be harder and harder to stick what we know to be developmentally appropriate with the rush to get everyone reading so early.

      Delete
  9. I AGREE!!!! As a pediatric Occupational Therapist this is what I continually try to inform parents, teachers, etc... Children need to work on skills where they are at developmentally and many 4 year olds may not even have the pre-printing skills to print all capital letters, never mind the lower case letters. If they are expected to print lower case too early they end up drawing letters instead of learning to print which leads to more problems later on! Children need solid building blocks in their foundation of fine motor skills and print! Thanks for your post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Heidi! I appreciate your professional opinion.

      Delete
  10. Do you have the name sheet available to purchase? I would love that for my Kindergarten kids so they can practice writing their name 4 different times :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Christy,
      I don't have that one available for purchase, but Powerful Mothering has a free one that you can download and customize for your children:
      http://www.powerfulmothering.com/free-personalized-my-name-tracing-printable/

      Enjoy :)

      Delete
  11. You've opened my eyes! I teach first so I didn't know this but I totally agree and your reasoning makes sense. I was just thinking about teaching Jackson how to write his name now (he can spell it) and I will encourage he start with capitals thanks to you!! Great post as always.
    Elyse :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Elyse! I would recommend following Jackson's lead! Now that he can spell it, keep working on fine motor skills and give him lots of opportunities to write, color and draw. It's likely that he will use capitals until he is closer to 5-years-old. What a lucky little guy to have you as his mom! ~Jamie

      Delete
  12. We live in Germany and even in kindergarten they can use capital letters. In the first grade they learn upper and lower case letters (they start first grade usually when 6y old). Most students do fine and don't have any problems although they used capital letters till then.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment, Diana. That's great to hear. It's important that we always consider what is best for the child!

      Delete
  13. Thanks for the explanation for reasoning behind teaching the capital letters first. I also have a master's degree in early childhood and years of experience teaching 5 yr. old's to write. It is frustrating to the student when they show up to kindergarten writing their names in all caps. It's for that reason that I think it's better to teach it in the way that their teacher will expect it to be written. I think lower case letters are similar in difficulty if you let the students write them large enough. I will continue making sand paper letters, in lower case for our 3 yr. old granddaughter and capitols so,\her mommy can teach which ever one she wants her to learn first. (Her mommy uses a really cool app. on her Ipad where the child traces the letters on the screen with their finger. Extra large font, too. Kora loves it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much for your comment, Betty, and for reading the blog. It sounds like you have lots of wonderful things in place to help your granddaughter learn her letters! With few exceptions, our students leave Pre-K and show up for kindergarten writing their names conventionally. I think they feel confident, and not frustrated. I appreciate you weighing in on the conversation!

      Delete
  14. Jessica8/19/2015

    I have to say, that I have always been firmly in the teach them the conventional way from the beginning camp, but your post definitely got me thinking. I've already made picture name cards the conventional way for this school year, but I think I'll make some of those name folders all upper and switch to conventional later in the year. Thanks for posting about a somewhat controversial topic, at least in the Early Childhood world.

    ReplyDelete